{
  "format": "houseir-public-review/1",
  "status": "scoped_automated_checks_passed",
  "professional_review": "pending; no architect approval or endorsement",
  "execution": "local API engine; named-opening fix not deployed to hosted API",
  "compiler_commit": "567d4ef0f7282001d688936983a33a42b00941c4",
  "conversion_source_code_sha256": "d30796108d2fc65b6770b98bc20802c168d7ad8ba49c7dbc1c4f3d7b2cd16167",
  "edit_source_code_sha256": "0f99929b7f1279c04634a1953956d65ecb91f207850d6716ab1609416a1dd5e3",
  "provenance_note": "Source conversion reused by verified artifact hash; compiler label fix occurred before the verified edit.",
  "ifc_sha256": {
    "original-color-coded.ifc": "b4c04a3358b59e9c5c23ec3938fa9c3a37118672af694d4534a1e564ae8fed5c",
    "changed-color-coded.ifc": "1d2de0a476958aab4c881104d7bc915fda4a086126b75549a22506eb7172a7c8",
    "original-raw.ifc": "70cc8ff245fc0894201d96496c031005a5cbd7a96b22d8a1b87c5a883fb77994",
    "changed-raw.ifc": "eeaec683f42015fc5f3b6da238191f214c070f38fdeed3b94b047d95319b1f1a"
  },
  "checks": {
    "source_products_retained": 127,
    "unchanged_product_semantics": true,
    "unchanged_existing_meshes": 107,
    "new_product_ids": [
      "0OnV8fHAvVLB8XjLt0pbMx",
      "27u$5tOHzQZgnDITs3S6mo",
      "2W7liKibrTU82Zsa6W56nw",
      "3fG5Ct6S5HHh1HieLIv8Ut"
    ],
    "wall_global_id": "2W7liKibrTU82Zsa6W56nw",
    "opening_global_id": "3fG5Ct6S5HHh1HieLIv8Ut",
    "wall_volume_m3": 0.3800000000000085,
    "expected_wall_volume_m3": 0.38,
    "all_added_wall_volume_m3": 1.0925000000000067,
    "all_expected_wall_volume_m3": 1.0925,
    "source_opening_volumes_screened": 17,
    "existing_physical_aabb_overlaps_over_1mm": [],
    "architectural_intent": {
      "verified": true,
      "checked": 3,
      "affected_ids": [
        "OfficeLink",
        "OfficePartition",
        "OfficePassage",
        "OfficeReturn"
      ],
      "wall_surfaces": [
        {
          "object_id": "OfficeLink",
          "ifc_id": "27u$5tOHzQZgnDITs3S6mo",
          "revision": "after",
          "verified": true,
          "upper_m": 2.6e-07,
          "plane_checks": 6,
          "reason": "bidirectional complete planar polygon containment"
        },
        {
          "object_id": "OfficePartition",
          "ifc_id": "2W7liKibrTU82Zsa6W56nw",
          "revision": "after",
          "verified": true,
          "upper_m": 3.3e-07,
          "plane_checks": 9,
          "reason": "bidirectional complete planar polygon containment"
        },
        {
          "object_id": "OfficeReturn",
          "ifc_id": "0OnV8fHAvVLB8XjLt0pbMx",
          "revision": "after",
          "verified": true,
          "upper_m": 2.6e-07,
          "plane_checks": 6,
          "reason": "bidirectional complete planar polygon containment"
        }
      ],
      "continuous_floor": [
        {
          "object_id": "OfficeLink",
          "uncovered_m2": 0.0
        },
        {
          "object_id": "OfficePartition",
          "uncovered_m2": 0.0
        },
        {
          "object_id": "OfficeReturn",
          "uncovered_m2": 0.0
        }
      ],
      "service_envelopes_checked": 0,
      "finished_floor_continuity": [],
      "unknown_proxy_envelopes_checked": 0,
      "service_completeness": "not_certified",
      "excluded_geometry": {
        "IfcAnnotation": {
          "counts": {
            "before": 14,
            "after": 14
          },
          "reason": "Annotations are not interpreted as physical service geometry; missing or misclassified systems remain unchecked."
        }
      },
      "engineering_design_certified": false,
      "scope": "rectangular walls and disjoint rectangular through openings; independent interval-cell surfaces; floor projection; conservative IfcDistributionElement and IfcBuildingElementProxy envelopes; other classifications and unmodeled systems are not certified"
    },
    "new_schema_problems": 0,
    "coloring": {
      "original": {
        "only_presentation_changed": true,
        "modified_styled_items": 154,
        "styled_representation_items": 191,
        "all_mesh_coordinates_and_triangles_unchanged": true,
        "new_schema_problems": 0
      },
      "changed": {
        "only_presentation_changed": true,
        "modified_styled_items": 154,
        "styled_representation_items": 195,
        "all_mesh_coordinates_and_triangles_unchanged": true,
        "new_schema_problems": 0
      }
    },
    "limitations": [
      "Source has no coordinated MEP.",
      "Existing space boundaries/areas remain unchanged; option is not a certified new room.",
      "No structural, egress, daylight, acoustic, HVAC, electrical or code approval.",
      "Clash screening uses AABBs for existing physical elements and opening voids; no code clearance certification.",
      "Source normative/EXPRESS issues may remain; no new structural schema errors is the claim."
    ]
  },
  "negative_control": {
    "rejected": true,
    "reason": "OfficePassage: opening must lie inside its host wall",
    "requested_opening_width_mm": 4000,
    "ifc_published": false
  },
  "focused_tests": {
    "architectural": 35,
    "related_generator_residual_service": 52,
    "failed": 0
  },
  "source_attribution": "IAI / Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), CC BY 4.0",
  "source_url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/sylvainHellin/ifc-bench/resolve/main/projects/fzk_house/arc.ifc"
}