HOUSEIR ARCHITECT REVIEW — FZK PARTITION OPTION, VERSION 1
Review status: independent architect review pending. No architect endorsement.
Suggested time: 15–20 minutes. Review only what you can actually inspect.

1. OPEN THE PAIR (2 MINUTES)
Open original-color-coded.ifc and changed-color-coded.ifc in your usual IFC tool.
Record the application/version in review-scorecard.txt or review-scorecard.html.
The website comparison is a convenient visual aid; inspect the actual IFCs before
judging import quality. Match your files to MANIFEST.json if possible. Record any
import warnings, missing geometry or appearance overrides. No RVT is included.

2. UNDERSTAND THE INTENT (3 MINUTES)
The proposal screens a work nook within the existing living area using three
connected, 100 mm-thick, 2500 mm-high partition sections and a 1000 by 2100 mm
access opening. The opening has no door leaf or hardware. Existing space volumes,
room boundaries and quantities have NOT been recalculated. This is an option to
evaluate, not a completed room redesign.

Hide roof/upper framing and logical space volumes. Compare plan and 3D views.
Magenta identifies the additions. The dogleg avoids a front window recess and
routes around the spiral stair. Do not assume those decisions establish usable
clearances, egress, daylight, ventilation or code compliance.

Target IDs (use these in findings; full indexes are in *-object-guide.txt):
OfficeReturn:    0OnV8fHAvVLB8XjLt0pbMx — short section near the front window.
OfficeLink:      27u$5tOHzQZgnDITs3S6mo — perpendicular connecting section.
OfficePartition: 2W7liKibrTU82Zsa6W56nw — section containing the access opening.
OfficePassage:   3fG5Ct6S5HHh1HieLIv8Ut — opening/void, normally invisible itself.

3. REVIEW THE DESIGN (5–8 MINUTES)
Check wall junctions, window reveals, stair approaches, access, furniture fit and
the purpose of the proposed nook. Inspect the floor at every new wall. No wall
removal or floor cut was requested. Check whether anything outside the declared
scope appears changed or lost. Record GlobalIds, view positions and screenshots
for issues; do not mark an unseen item acceptable.

The source is architectural only, without coordinated HVAC, plumbing or electrical
systems. Identify the systems work needed if this option were adopted. No claim
is made that this source house was built or approved under a particular code.

4. DISTINGUISH EVIDENCE FROM JUDGMENT (3 MINUTES)
AUTOMATED, ALREADY RECORDED:
- 127 existing IFC products preserved; 4 products added; none removed.
- 107 existing meshes retain identical vertices/triangles in the raw pair.
- Independent requested-wall surfaces, cutout and volumes passed.
- Supporting floor coverage: zero uncovered area beneath all three new walls.
- Supplementary AABB screen: no >1 mm overlap with existing physical objects or
  the 17 tessellated source opening voids. This is not a comprehensive clash test.
- No new structural schema/attribute problems; bounded touched-product EXPRESS
  checks ran. Full-model normative compliance was not certified.
- Color derivatives retain geometry and non-style entities.
- A deliberately oversized opening was refused without publishing an IFC.
- 87 focused tests passed; these are not independent architectural approval.

FOR YOU TO JUDGE (NOT AUTOMATICALLY PASSED):
Import usability in your software; layout/furniture/circulation; practical wall
and finish details; stair/egress safety; daylight/ventilation; structural support;
required MEP changes; usefulness; information missing before design development.

5. COMPLETE AND RETURN THE SCORECARD (2–4 MINUTES)
Use the editable online scorecard, or fill in review-scorecard.txt.
Choose Not reviewed / Needs changes / Acceptable for concept review / N/A for
each criterion. List blockers and the next changes you would request. State
whether you would use this workflow, for what task, and why.

Download your completed scorecard and email it to sneakybenson@gmail.com, or
discuss it at https://houseir.unum11.com/book.html . The online form does not
submit or save your answers to a server. Download before closing it.
Do not send confidential client models through this public review form.

Review feedback is not permission to quote your name, firm or comments publicly.
Any attribution/testimonial permission must be requested separately. An acceptable
concept score is not permit approval or engineering certification.

PROVENANCE
The recorded geometric edit was run on the local HouseIR compiler. A named-opening
fix used here has not yet been deployed to the hosted API. Exact hosted parity for
this workflow must be verified before it is committed as a hosted pilot scope.
Model: IAI / Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, CC BY 4.0. See source-license.txt.
